Dappered

Affordable Men's Style

  • Don’t Miss Anything
  • Start Here
  • Essentials Shop
  • Latest Deals
  • Style Scenarios
  • Reviews
  • Forum

The search for the perfect modern wingtip – Johnston & Murphy

November 19, 2010 By Joe | Heads up: Buying via our links may result in us getting a commission. Also, we take your privacy rights seriously. Head here to learn more.

Johnston & Murphy Waverly Wingtip Oxford – $164.95

Click here for the previous candidate, the Cole Haan Air Garrett

Sleek looking in silhouette and not too clunky in the toe.  That’s all it takes to qualify for this ongoing search for the perfect modern wingtip.  Since affordability is a focus here, price has to be taken into consideration as well.

For well over $150, a shoe better be almost perfect.  And the J&M Murphy comes up short.  Literally in the toe, while being a little long on the price tag.  Here’s the breakdown after an in-person fitting:

Not as modern from the top.

The Pros

  • Closed lacing
  • Solid feeling construction.  Not too weighty, but solid.
  • Easy to find at multiple retailers (Nordstrom, Dillard’s, Zappos)
  • Leather sole
  • Toebox can accommodate wider feet
  • Goodyear welt construction

The Cons

  • That 3/4 shot is not a true representation of the toe.  See right instead ->
  • Toe is a more rounded Allen Edmonds style.  Needs a little more length in the toe for the slightly elongated look of an A. Testoni.
  • Downright expensive at $165.  Ouch.

The Verdict

Damn.  Seeing it online and in person is just flat out a different story.  When you try the shoes on, stand up, and look down at your feet from above… they’re just about half an inch too short in the toe to be truly considered modern.  They’re ALMOST there.  But not quite.  A smart play for a more conservative environment, but if not?  Save yourself $30 and get the Cole Haan Garretts.
.

Got a comment or want to share your experience with Johnston & Murphy?  Leave it below.
Here’s the slightly more modern looking Cole Haan Garrett.  Available for $135…

Cole Haan at ShopStyle

Filed Under: Shoes Tagged With: Cole Haan, Dress Shoes, johnston & murphy, lace ups, oxfords, search for the perfect modern wingtip, Wingtips

Continue the Conversation …

Want to share your thoughts on this article? Send us a tweet, join the discussion on Facebook, or start a discussion on Dappered Threads, our forum!

Don’t Miss Anything

Subscribe via email to get articles in your inbox or add Dappered on Flipboard. You can also follow us on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram. Or subscribe to push notifications to get alerts immediately.

New Here?

Well, welcome to Dappered. Here are what we consider the most useful posts on the site if you're looking to put a little more effort into your appearance. Just want to see our favorite menswear products? Shop our essentials here.

Sale on Huckberry’s USA Made Trucker, Vegan Samba Restock, & More – The Thurs. Men’s Sales Handful

Sale on Huckberry’s USA Made Trucker, Vegan Samba Restock, & More – The Thurs. Men’s Sales Handful

Now updated with Brooks Brothers, who is running a nice deal on their Golden Fleece shoes.

How to Spend it: So you got a gift card to Amazon

How to Spend it: So you got a gift card to Amazon

Amazon. Big (biggest?) haystack, but a few “style” needles can be found.

Style Scenario: Modern Mod (black and gray smart casual)

Style Scenario: Modern Mod (black and gray smart casual)

Sleek layers. Black. Grays. A bit of dark brown suede.

Follow Dappered on Instagram »

Comments

  1. Manny says

    November 19, 2010 at 6:58 AM

    I constantly write that I am looking for shoes that are sleek, low profile, and modern. Hehe Also that I find every other shoe just too clunky. Well I finally found a the shoe that is “Modern” looking for me and I like but it comes with a huge price tag but this is what I feel is what a shoe should feel and look like for me not because of price but because it’s about fit just as in clothing.
    I wouldn’t wear an over-sized shirt now so likewise why wear an oversized shoe in regards to those chunky soles, chunky toes, and chunky leather. 🙂 These babies but I can’t find them in black.

  2. Nate says

    November 19, 2010 at 7:49 AM

    I picked up a pair of Air Garret’s shortly after you reviewed them- Nordstrom briefly had them on sale for $99, which I just couldn’t pass up. I’ve only worn them a couple times, but they are pretty impressive, and I’ve gotten several compliments. The mahogany color is a bit darker than it appears in most online photos, but quite handsome. I have heard some grumblings about Cole Haan leather quality (crinkling at flex-points, etc.), so I’m hoping for the best, but I don’t think I could’ve done better for a C-Note.

  3. Rich says

    November 19, 2010 at 8:44 AM

    What a coincidence, I just picked up the J&M Waverlys last week.
    I must say, I disagree with Joe (a rare event!) that they come up short at the $160 price point. I wear a size 10.5 and have a muscular build but fairly skinny legs. Often, I feel more “modern” shoes exaggerate the size of my feet precisely because their subtle contours make them appear TOO long and sleek. I like my footwear more traditional. I also wanted a pair that I could wear with jeans, so I wanted some heft to them (but with modern construction so that they remain light in weight). The Waverlys are perfect in this regard.
    My pair shares a similar silhouette with the Allen Edmond’s McAllister but at half the price ($325 was too far for me to go for the AEs). I also like that my pair of J&Ms have a slightly more sloped toe (less rounded) so they look more aggressive and masculine. I think they are they are perfect pair for me.
    Also, unlike some other black wingtips which are criticized for not looking as rich or lustrous because the black leather looks cheap – these hand polished beauties have a real depth to them.
    I would definitely try them on for yourself before dropping more on a more expensive pair, they represent much better in person!

  4. Bryan says

    November 19, 2010 at 8:59 AM

    That top-down pic looks like they are made for people with super wide paddle feet or something lol

  5. John says

    November 19, 2010 at 9:25 AM

    shoebuy.com has these. Use coupon code EMLTHXGIVING10. This knocks 20% off. $132.00 shipped.

  6. Kinky says

    November 19, 2010 at 11:57 AM

    John, where were you 2 days when I bought these for $165! I may order them from that site and return them to J&M.

Men’s Fashion or Affordable Style?

Men's Fashion or Affordable Style?

Fashion is temporary and expensive. Style is timeless and affordable. Dappered® helps you work the retail system so that you can be comfortable, look sharp, and save money.

Want to share a great product? Email Us.
Continue the discussion at Dappered Threads.
For a fit perspective, see Joe's measurements.
Make sure to read our affiliate disclosure.

Connect with Dappered

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Most Popular on Dappered

  • Steal Alert: J. Crew Extra 50% off Sale Styles + Stock Refresh
  • Monday Men’s Sales Tripod – Levis x Target, Tasty Nike Deals, & More
  • Henley Palooza 2021 – The Best Looking Affordable Henleys for Men
  • J. Crew 50% off Select (again)… with new Spring arrivals
  • Sale on Huckberry’s USA Made Trucker, Vegan Samba Restock, & More – The Thurs. Men’s Sales Handful
  • The Best in Affordable Style from the Month that Was – February 2021

Popular Topics

  • Best dress shirts to own
  • Best looking watches under $100
  • Best men’s dress shoes under $200
  • Nike Killshot sneaker alternatives
  • How to wear a suit without a tie
  • Suitsupply store review
  • Suitsupply Blue Line review
  • J. Crew Factory Thompson suit review
  • How much does it cost to tailor a suit?
  • Dopp kit essentials
  • Brown shoes with gray pants
  • Men’s style buying guide

RSS Latest on Dappered Threads

  • Adding Brands to the Dappered Website
  • Altering Boardshorts?
  • Crown & Caliber sold to Hodinkee
  • J. Crew Court Classic Sneakers
  • BR athletic tapered?

Copyright © 2021 Dappered.com | Dappered, LLC | Dappered® is a registered trademark of Dappered, LLC

Hat tip: Magazine Pro Theme On Genesis Framework

Dappered does not collect or sell its users personal information | Disclosures: Privacy and Affiliates, Gilt.com, FTC

WPE

We work with partners that use cookies to understand how visitors use our site. Find out more.