Style debate: Tie loosened with a tie clip?

Tie clip + loosened tie = Good or bad?

There’s something sartorially backwards about wearing a tie clip then not buttoning the top button on your shirt.  A tie clip’s purpose is to keep your tie under control.  And then you unbutton your shirt collar and let the knot hang loose and free?

J. Crew (that’s a Ludlow suit you see above) uses this look extensively and it does show off the rumpled but still dressed up image that the brand has mastered.  But is this “I just had a long day and now I’m at happy hour” look best left to the pages of catalogs?

Have you executed this in public, would you consider it, would you not, and why?

Leave it all in the comments section below.

Gotta hand it to J. Crew on the tie clip itself.  Perfectly simple and sterling silver. $60.

Joe

Recent Posts

1 Sale, 5 Outfits: Spier & Mackay Anniversary Sale

Core line suits. Dress Shoes. Black Tie. Casual stuff. Giving Spier's Anniversary sale the 5…

23 hours ago

Chinos, Chukkas, Polo: Budget Bond – Splurge, but not luxury brands

Spending a bit more, but not nearly "I got the Mi6 credit card" levels.

1 day ago

Chinos, Chukkas, Polo: Budget Bond – CHEAP

007? More like $0.07. Not that cheap, but the focus is firmly fixed on affordability.…

2 days ago

Monday Men’s Sales Tripod – J. Crew Extra 60% off Final Sale, Spier Shoes Sale, & More

There's a pretty solid stunner of a stacking (Italian made) suit sale at Brooks Brothers.

2 days ago

1 Sale, 5 Outfits: Banana Republic 30% off

Five style scenarios mined from BR's quiet 30% off code.

4 days ago

Steal Alert: Banana Republic 30% off Full Price Secret Sale

Tropical wool suits. Core temp pants and shorts. It's quiet and it's quick. Not promoted…

6 days ago